Chapter 2

Sāṅkhya (साङ्ख्य)

Kṛṣṇa (कृष्ण) answers. The self is not the body. Action is a right, not a claim on the fruit.

Summary

Chapter 2 is the answer that carries the book. The self is not born and does not die. What dies is the body. For the warrior, his own dharma is the fight in front of him. Action is his, the fruit is not. The last part describes the person of steady insight, who is not shaken by the pairs.

नेपालीमा

अध्याय २ पुस्तकलाई बोकेको जवाफ हो। आत्मा जन्मिँदैन र मर्दैन। मर्ने त शरीर हो। क्षत्रियका लागि आफ्नो धर्म सामुन्नेको लडाइँ हो। कर्म उहाँको हो, फल होइन। अन्तिम भागले स्थिर प्रज्ञ भएको मानिसको वर्णन गर्छ, जसलाई द्वन्द्वले हल्लाउँदैन।

1–10 Sañjaya (सञ्जय), श्रीभगवान् Śrī Bhagavān, Arjuna (अर्जुन) · The friend refuses the collapse

Summary

Kṛṣṇa (कृष्ण) refuses the collapse. This faintness does not belong to a noble man and does not lead to heaven. Arjuna answers that he cannot aim at Bhīṣma (भीष्म) and Droṇa (द्रोण). He asks to be taught, and then falls silent. The friend has become the student. The teaching has not started.

नेपालीमा

कृष्णले भत्किनुलाई अस्वीकार गर्नुहुन्छ। यो मूर्छा आर्यलाई सुहाउँदैन र स्वर्गतिर लैजाँदैन। अर्जुन भीष्म र द्रोणमाथि बाण हान्न सक्दिनँ भनी जवाफ दिन्छन्। उनी सिकाइ माग्छन्, अनि चुप लाग्छन्। मित्र विद्यार्थी भएका छन्। उपदेश भने अझै सुरु भएको छैन।

2.1Sañjaya (सञ्जय) said: Madhusūdana (मधुसूदन) spoke this speech to him, thus overcome by pity, his eyes full of tears and agitated, despairing.2.2Kṛṣṇa (कृष्ण) said: From where has this faintness come upon you in the crisis, Arjuna — unpracticed by the noble, not leading to heaven, a maker of disgrace?2.3Do not go into unmanliness, son of Pṛthā (पृथा), for this does not fit you, and having left this petty weakness of the heart, stand up, scorcher of the foe.2.4Arjuna said: How shall I fight back in battle with arrows against Bhīṣma (भीष्म) and Droṇa (द्रोण), Madhusūdana (मधुसूदन), the two who are worthy of worship, slayer of enemies?2.5Not having killed these great-souled teachers, it is better to eat even alms here in the world; having killed the teachers, desirous of gain though they are, I would enjoy right here pleasures smeared with blood.2.6And we do not know which of the two is weightier for us, whether we should conquer or they should conquer us; those very sons of Dhṛtarāṣṭra (धृतराष्ट्र), having killed whom we would not wish to live, are standing in front.2.7My nature is wrecked by pity. I ask you. Tell me what is better. I am your student.2.8I do not see what would drive off this grief of mine that dries up the senses, even having obtained on the earth an unrivaled prosperous kingship, and overlordship even of the gods.2.9Having said "I will not fight," he goes silent.2.10Hṛṣīkeśa (हृषीकेश), almost smiling, spoke this word to the despairing man, O Bhārata, in the middle of both armies.QuizFive questions on The friend refuses the collapse.

11–30 श्रीभगवान् Śrī Bhagavān · The self

Summary

The self is not the one who dies. Bodies are said to end. The one who dwells in the body is not born and is not killed. Heat, cold, pleasure, and pain come and go and are to be borne. What is real does not cease. The section is the Sāṅkhya (साङ्ख्य) of this chapter, the seeing, before the fight is given back as duty.

नेपालीमा

आत्मा मर्ने होइन। शरीरको अन्त्य हुन्छ भनिन्छ। शरीरमा बस्ने न जन्मन्छ, न मारिन्छ। तातो, चिसो, सुख र दुःख आउँछन् र जान्छन्, तिनलाई सहनुपर्छ। जे वास्तविक छ, त्यो कहिल्यै नाश हुँदैन। यो खण्ड यस अध्यायको साङ्ख्य हो, अर्थात् दृष्टि, लडाइँ कर्तव्यका रूपमा फर्काइनुभन्दा अघिको।

2.11You mourn what is not to be mourned, and you speak words that sound like wisdom.2.12Never was there a time I was not, nor you, nor these lords of men; and never, from now on, shall all of us not be.2.13As the embodied one passes through childhood, youth, and age in this body, so he passes to another body.2.14Contacts of the senses, son of Kuntī (कुन्ती), give cold and heat, pleasure and pain; they come and go and do not last; endure them, Bhārata.2.15The man whom these do not shake, O bull among men — the steady man for whom pain and pleasure are the same — he is fit for deathlessness.2.16What is not does not come to be. What is does not cease to be.2.17Know that to be indestructible by which all this is spread; no one is able to make the destruction of this imperishable.2.18These bodies of the eternal, indestructible, immeasurable embodied one are said to have an end; therefore fight, Bhārata.2.19Who holds this one to be a killer, and who thinks this one killed — those two do not know; this one does not kill and is not killed.2.20It is not born and does not die. It is not killed when the body is killed.2.21The man who knows this one as indestructible, eternal, unborn, and imperishable — how, son of Pṛthā (पृथा), does he cause anyone to be killed, or whom does he kill?2.22As a man leaves worn-out clothes and takes others, so the embodied one leaves worn-out bodies.2.23Weapons do not cut this one, fire does not burn him, the waters do not wet him, and the wind does not dry him.2.24This one is not to be cut, not to be burned, not to be wetted, and not to be dried; he is eternal, present everywhere, firm, unmoving, ancient.2.25This one is called unmanifest, unthinkable, and not to be changed; therefore, having known him thus, you ought not to grieve.2.26But if you think this one constantly born and constantly dead, even so, strong-armed one, you ought not to grieve in this way.2.27What is born will die. What has died will be born. You are not the one who ought to grieve.2.28Beings are unmanifest at the beginning, manifest in the middle, and unmanifest at the end, Bhārata; what lament is there in that?2.29Someone sees this one as a wonder, another speaks of him just so as a wonder, and another hears of him as a wonder; and even having heard, no one knows him.2.30This embodied one is eternally not to be killed, Bhārata, in everyone's body; therefore you ought not to grieve for any being.QuizFive questions on The self.

31–38 श्रीभगवान् Śrī Bhagavān · The fight as his own dharma

Summary

The fight is given back as his own dharma. A warrior's door to heaven, in these verses, is a war that comes unasked. Refusing it from fear is the stain, not the fighting. The section speaks to Arjuna's station. It does not generalise the battlefield into a rule for every hearer.

नेपालीमा

लडाइँ उनकै धर्मका रूपमा फर्काइन्छ। यी श्लोकमा क्षत्रियका लागि स्वर्गको ढोका नमागी आइपरेको युद्ध हो। डरले त्यसलाई अस्वीकार गर्नु दाग हो, लड्नु होइन। यो खण्ड अर्जुनको स्थानसँग बोल्छ। यसले रणभूमिलाई हरेक सुन्नेका लागि नियम बनाउँदैन।

39–53 श्रीभगवान् Śrī Bhagavān · The buddhi, and the right to the act

Summary

The buddhi, and the right to the act. The insight declared now is the yoga of the buddhi. Action is yours. The fruit is not a claim. The pairs are what the buddhi has to stand equal toward. The Vedic promises of fruit are set lower than this steadiness. The section is the line the rest of the poem keeps returning to.

नेपालीमा

बुद्धि र कर्ममाथिको अधिकार। अब भनिएको प्रज्ञा बुद्धियोग हो। कर्म तिम्रो हो। फल दाबी गर्ने कुरा होइन। बुद्धिले द्वन्द्वहरूप्रति समान भएर उभिनुपर्छ। फलका वैदिक प्रतिज्ञा यो स्थिरताभन्दा तल राखिन्छन्। यो खण्ड बाँकी कविताले बारम्बार फर्केर आउने पङ्क्ति हो।

2.39This buddhi has been declared to you in Sāṅkhya (साङ्ख्य); now hear it in yoga, Pārtha (पार्थ) — yoked with it, you will cast off the bondage of action.2.40Here no undertaking is lost, and no falling back is found; even a little of this dharma saves from great fear.2.41Here the buddhi of resolve is one, joy of the Kurus; the understandings of the unresolved are many-branched and endless.2.42The undiscerning, delighting in talk of the Veda (वेद), utter this flowery speech, arguing "there is nothing else," Pārtha (पार्थ).2.43Those whose self is desire, and for whom heaven is the summit, utter the speech that grants fruits of birth and of works, thick with special rites, aimed at enjoyment and power.2.44For those attached to enjoyment and lordship, whose minds that speech has carried off, the buddhi of resolve is not established in samādhi (समाधि).2.45The Vedas (वेद) have the three qualities as their subject; be free of the three, Arjuna (अर्जुन) — free of the pairs, standing always in sattva (सत्त्व), free of getting and keeping, possessed of the self.2.46As much use as a well has when water is flooded on every side, that much use do all the Vedas (वेद) have for the brahmin who discerns.2.47Your right is to the action alone, never to its fruits.2.48Standing in yoga, do the acts. Evenness is called yoga.2.49Action is far inferior to the yoga of buddhi, Dhanañjaya (धनञ्जय); seek refuge in the buddhi. Wretched are those whose motive is the fruit.2.50Yoga is skill in actions.2.51The wise who are joined with buddhi, having left the fruit born of action, freed from the bondage of birth, go to the place that does not ail.2.52When your buddhi crosses the thicket of delusion, then you will come to dispassion toward what is yet to be heard and what has already been heard.2.53When your buddhi, pulled about by what you have heard, stands unmoving and unwavering in samādhi (समाधि), then you will reach yoga.QuizFive questions on The buddhi, and the right to the act.

54–72 Arjuna (अर्जुन), श्रीभगवान् Śrī Bhagavān · The man of steady insight

Summary

Arjuna asks for the marks of the person of steady insight. Kṛṣṇa (कृष्ण) answers. That person is not shaken by grief or by longing. The senses withdraw, as a tortoise draws in its limbs. Desire hidden in the senses is what wrecks the knowing. The section ends at night for beings and day for the sage, and at the peace that is not a bargain.

नेपालीमा

अर्जुनले स्थिर प्रज्ञ भएको मानिसका चिह्न सोध्छन्। कृष्णले जवाफ दिनुहुन्छ। त्यस्तो व्यक्ति शोक र लालसाले हल्लिँदैन। कछुवाले अङ्ग भित्र तानेझैँ उसका इन्द्रिय फर्कन्छन्। इन्द्रियमा लुकेको इच्छाले ज्ञानलाई भत्काउँछ। यो खण्ड प्राणीका लागि रात र मुनिका लागि दिन भएको कुरामा, र मोलतोल नभएको शान्तिमा टुङ्गिन्छ।

2.54Arjuna (अर्जुन) said: What is the description of the man of steady insight, the one who stands in samādhi (समाधि), Keśava (केशव)? How would the steady-minded man speak, how sit, how walk?2.55When he throws off all desires that have entered the mind, and is content in the self by the self alone, then he is called a man of steady insight, Pārtha (पार्थ).2.56He whose mind is unshaken in pains, whose longing has gone in pleasures, and from whom attraction, fear, and anger have left, is called a sage of steady mind.2.57Who has no clinging anywhere, and who, meeting this or that, pleasant or unpleasant, does not rejoice and does not hate — his insight stands firm.2.58And when he draws the senses in from their objects, as a tortoise draws in its limbs, his insight stands firm.2.59The objects turn back from the embodied one who does not feed on them, but the relish remains; even his relish turns back when the highest is seen.2.60Even of a striving, discerning man, the churning senses carry off the mind by force, son of Kuntī (कुन्ती).2.61Having restrained all those, he should sit yoked, holding me as the highest; his insight stands firm whose senses are in his control.2.62Dwelling on objects, a man forms attachment. From attachment, desire. From desire, anger.2.63From anger comes bewilderment; from bewilderment, the wandering of memory; from the fall of memory, the ruin of the buddhi; from the ruin of the buddhi, he is lost.2.64But the man whose self is governable, moving among objects with senses freed from attraction and aversion and held in the self's control, reaches clarity.2.65In that clarity, the falling away of all his pains arises, and the buddhi of the clear-minded man quickly stands firm.2.66There is no buddhi for the unyoked, and no meditation for the unyoked; for the one who does not meditate there is no peace, and for the unpeaceful, from where is happiness?2.67The mind that follows the roaming senses carries off his insight, as the wind carries a boat on the water.2.68Therefore, great-armed one, his insight stands firm whose senses are held back on every side from their objects.2.69What is night for all beings, in that the man of restraint is awake; that in which beings are awake is night for the sage who sees.2.70As waters enter the ocean that is being filled and yet does not move in its foundation, so the man whom all desires enter reaches peace, and the desirer of desires does not.2.71The man who walks having left all desires, without longing, comes to peace.2.72This is the standing that belongs to brahman (ब्रह्मन्), Pārtha (पार्थ); having reached it, one is not deluded, and standing in it even at the time of the end, he reaches the nirvāṇa (निर्वाण) that is brahman (ब्रह्मन्).QuizFive questions on The man of steady insight.